A tale of two cities: Cave Creek vs. Scottsdale over title - FOX 35 News Orlando

A tale of two cities: Cave Creek vs. Scottsdale over 'most western' title

Posted: Updated:
  • Must Read HeadlinesMore>>

  • The Mormon Bachelorette star finds love outside of the show

    The Mormon Bachelorette star finds love outside of the show

    Ashley Chapman has gone from a single girl to part of a double couple on the verge of a double wedding.
    Ashley Chapman has gone from a single girl to part of a double couple on the verge of a double wedding.
  • Sub records detailed images of WWII wreck

    Sub records detailed images of WWII wreck

    Thursday, April 24 2014 2:44 PM EDT2014-04-24 18:44:31 GMT
    An unmanned submarine has recorded some of the most detailed images of two American ships that sank off the coast of England during World War II, according to the Massachusetts company that surveyed the wreckage to...
    An unmanned submarine has recorded some of the most detailed images of two American ships that sank off the coast of England during World War II, according to the Massachusetts company that surveyed the wreckage to mark...
  • Ronald McDonald takes to Twitter, gets makeover

    Ronald McDonald takes to Twitter, gets makeover

    Ronald McDonald has a new look, and he's ready for a selfie. McDonald's said its famous spokesclown will take an active role on social media for the first time, using the hashtag #ronaldmcdonald.
    Ronald McDonald has a new look, and he's ready for a selfie. McDonald's said its famous spokesclown will take an active role on social media for the first time, using the hashtag #ronaldmcdonald.
CAVE CREEK, Ariz. -

A wild west showdown is brewing between two valley cities.

Since 1951, Scottsdale's official motto has been "the west's most western town." It's even written on the city's official seal below an image of a wild horse.

Another valley city wants to lay claim to that title -- but Scottsdale isn't going to let that happen without a fight.

Cave Creek claims that Scottsdale long ago turned its back on its old western heritage, and embraced the new economy -- high-rises, shopping malls -- and is now actually marketing itself as a place to get new medical care.

It's no doubt that Cave Creek has retained its western heritage and charm, and so its leaders have drafted a resolution that challenges Scottsdale's claim as the west's most western town.

To bring things further, Cave Creek has also challenged Scottsdale city leaders to a bull riding competition and a quick draw shootout at Cave Creek's Wild West Days in November.

If Cave Creek gets its way, the winner of those events will take the title of the west's most western town.

"Long ago, Scottsdale traded in their spring horseshoes for spring training. They decided shopping malls were more important than focusing on sustainability and hiking and being western. We're about boots, they're about suits," said Rodney Glassman, Cave Creek's interim town manager.

Unfortunately for Cave Creek, Scottsdale's slogan is copyrighted. So regardless who may win a shootout or competition, that slogan, more than 60 years old, isn't going anywhere.

"In some ways it's some harmless fun. A little camaraderie or competitiveness between the two towns or cities, and promotes who we both are. But no they just can't come and take it," said Scottsdale city councilman Dennis Robbins.

Regardless of whether it's fun and games or a serious move, it's got people talking, and is drumming up some publicity for Cave Creek's Wild West Days.

By the way, the resolution was approved at Monday's council meeting. Just about everyone was dressed in western gear.

Said one Cave Creek cowgirl, Jean Glass, at the meeting, "We're the real deal."

Added Larry Wendt, "I'll tell you what, we'll have a shootout for it, we'll flip a coin, card game, we'll be fair -- but we're taking the name. A lot of people didn't want to give it up in the west, and they had to!"

It's not clear what action Scottsdale will take next.

What do you think? Which city deserves the title more? Leave us a comment below!

Didn't find what
you were looking for?

Powered by WorldNow

35 Skyline Drive
Lake Mary, FL 32746

Phone: (407) 644-3535
News Tips: (866) 55-FOX35

Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Ad Choices